On one hand, stealth is the most difficult thing for newbies to learn. On the other, they shouldn't have a target on their backs, It would be odd for a starter thief guild to not have all traditional thief skills. A "hunter" guild with bow/knife that would hunt animals for money would be c...

I think it would be really cool. But didn't the guildmaster leave gen? Seems like a consent issue. I propose an alternative, the "Order of the Glittering Unicorn" that is functionally identical but thematically different enough to be considered our own intellectual property. Bronie Knights...

I like the idea of setting attributes in character creation, such as alignment. Although this would drive us closer to class-based, an "all human stats" system with variants toward warrior, mage, and thief would be interesting.

Sounds cool. A cheap shot to avoid combat and escape, with emphasis on exploration. I support pacifist/craft thieves!

It seems to me that currently thieves are used for combat more than anything else, as half the stuff is unpickable. Cheap shot+backstab with skills increased to occ level is the only way I personally see them being used

TL:DR Remove the dexterity-penalty on the dwarf (equal a human) Make a (working) rogue-type guild for the hobbit/kender Wait for Arman to fix the magic system for the gnome and elf Make humans great again! I agree with pretty much the whole thing, except humans. Until the magic recode they're king,...

Cherek is my #1 former AoE turned Keeper

It will be interesting to see how many exist in 90 days. It would be cool to see a chart of the top tier items and how many exist that you could check in game

It will be faster for evils to become good.. and slower for goodies to become evil. I would find that to be an excellent solution. :) Thematically I think that's strange. Why not impose restrictions on evil guilds themselves to keep it "harder" to be good but not give evil the freedom to ...

I think a lot of the alignment argument is a symptom of not having enough enemies to grind. Of course there are other things, like EQ availability, quests, etc.

If we think about it irl, you probably wouldn't trust your friend to be a Knight of Solamnia if they had spent years murdering civilians under the banner of Takhisis. In many cases killing people who are innocent, even if closer to neutral is frowned upon. I like Arman's idea of factions, but that w...