Genesis Forums

Long ago I heard that the smith in Palanthas makes really good weapons. Is there anywhere that makes better weapons?

Don't know to be honest.
Blacksmith guild members making there own stuff after 1000's of times should be really good, hopefully better than npc offerings.

Bubba in Gelan is popular.
Tyr has good stuff too I think.

As well as smiths there are shops near many guilds where u can buy starter weapons if nothing in the racks.


If u want to know which is best test it yourself.
Time how long it takes to kill x number of same sized enemies using the weapon and no specials.
repeat for the others

Okay! According to my appraises at sup craft, here they are.

Long polearms from Bubba
Palanthas weapons
Short weapons from Bubba

Can't check Tyr atm cuz Tentavvar appears to be glitched. Will edit it in, though.

I am curious about this as well...

Reached the conclusion best weapon smith for 1h weapons is Palanthas.

Seemly Bubba is best at polearms.

Tyr is best for 2H weapons if you don't mind the weight... Unless you figure how to make steel weapons I guess (Is that even possible? I never figured how).


Sadly, the Smiths Guild weapons, suck. Smiths Guild for actual forging is rather useless unless you doing it for the money (to sell to NPCs, not to players).