Killing an enemies smaller weaker guild mates is called hitting your enemy where it hurts.
The sort of thing that leads to all out guild wars.
Which is not necessarily a bad state of affairs. As a good war will be a talking point of years to come.
Its up to their guild to get treaties in place to protect the weaker members or to help them recover.
A small knight like Chamdin dying is not surprising.
But would he rather be told you are not allowed to join until titan because its too dangerous?
Also one of the benefits of being in a warlike guild should be that they are close knit and willing to help
each other recover. Given he is smaller than the other Knights have they pitched in and taken him
killing to get him back where he was? Thats how it used to happen in most I think.
But most times I have seen Chamdin he has been solo so maybe guild help is not as common.
Yet the experience of being attacked because of who he was not what he had done was a learning one.
It will have to be expected in certain guilds.
Where this crosses the line is when it is in a guild that has no real ties to one another.
For example killing a lot of gladiators because one pissed you off.
Whats interesting is in Rhynox's example of staying out of wars etc because of weaker members.
Since the guild is only as strong as its weakest link.
Killing hurt players, well, if two people are enemies you don't walk away from an advantage.
A chivalrous player like Rhynox is the minority, most people take what they can get.
There are a lot of old grudges that fester under the surface until you see an opportunity too good to pass up.