Meeting with orc MM in Krynn

[Kas]

Hmm, if this is about Ydred finding a new home, why is this a problem?

[Laurel]

I have an issue with alts - always had in this game.

[Irk]

he doesnt complain about changing guild, but from which to which he jumped and after attacking allies, isnt obvious?

Kas: i didnt attack straight the ally, i was cleaning war zone from DA. One of the npcs there is human. Unfortunately i didnt notice that one of the human wasn't DA that I was fighting. However we explained all and I apologized the Knights for my behaviour. On the other hand Knight could leave the room, when he saw that dwarf is fighting him.

Amberlee: sorry to disappoint you, but I dont have script to clean war zones, so your theory fails

[Irk]

Hmm, if this is about Ydred finding a new home, why is this a problem?

I am not the best RP player, but i guess it is RP problem

[Amberlee]

lol Irk..
I was there on one of the occations where you attacked a Knight.
So stop lying.

[Laurel]

Hmm, if this is about Ydred finding a new home, why is this a problem?

Except for some alliance or smth between Niggets, Rangers, Neidar and Calia ... none I can think of.
When Irk attacks someone - said alliance seems to exist as an argument.
When a Ranger outlaw and Neidar attacker becomes a squire, the same alliance seems irrelevant for exactly the same people.

Hip hip hipocrisy

[Laurel]

lol Irk..
I was there on one of the occations where you attacked a Knight.
So stop lying.

I think you lost creditibility already - you are the lier here, my polish-heritage named friend.

[Irk]

lol Irk..
I was there on one of the occations where you attacked a Knight.
So stop lying.

and where exactly i lied? be more specific.
I see you know better how i play this game

[Laurel]

Some of us should only be allowed in flame section

Me!
"Come with me, mortal one."

[Kas]

Ah, right.

Don't know anything about the due process of becoming a knight though.

Regarding the rp for switching between those two guilds, it doesn't necessarily point to bad play (not defending anyone here though). If the reason, the idea and the switchover makes sense or is well played out, I see a few ways how it could work out (not including allies here and that part), like redemption in some form or another, and the gap between being alive and undead could be played to be huge/enormous for the psyche for the candidate, triggering radical changes in pattern of thinking and renewed mortal emotions.

Ofcourse, that's just one side of it, The knights may need to be on their term be convinced of the sincerety of the candidate and the potential for future knighthood, and, not trying to be apologetic here but even knights may behave abnormal or even radical without breaking the RP in any way.

It's a potential false dichotomy to say that one must rp'ing a knight(any guild possibly) in a certain fasion in order for it to be labeled as 'good RP', (else it's bad RP), because there is a possibility to 'Act' as a good knight while actually being sinister or have alternative goals, and in heart forfeiting the Oath and the Measure alltogether.

Did Lord Soth RP badly when he crossed the line(s)?