Re: Libraries - (semi)Unified System
Posted: 22 Jan 2021 22:40
I thoroughly agree with Cherek here.
The Official Genesis MUD Forums
https://www.genesismud.org/forums/
I do not agree that things working differently is not a problem, even if I am not as appreciative as you are.Cherek wrote: ↑22 Jan 2021 22:06Why there is no standard template library that can be pulled and reskinned? Well, because nobody has made one? Or maybe someone has, but only newer libraries use it, and not the ones created in the 90s? I don't know. We have a lot of different libraries... it would be a massive job to go through them all and "standardise" them. Could it be done? Maybe, but is it worth the effort, and will it even make the game better? I think it would be better to invididually fix the worst offenders when it comes to syntaxes, but let them keep their uniqueness.
My whole point was that I think these variances, while quirky, is also part of what Genesis is. If we were a commercial game company, we would likely have standard templayes for all sorts of things, and a coherent theme and feel for the entire game. But we don't, and I personally also think that IS part of the charm as well. It's the same with all our different kind of shops, inns, pubs, and other establishments. Sometimes you buy stuff, sometimes you order it, sometimes you read a menu, sometimes a pricelist, sometimes reading is forbidden so you have to examine pictures, and sometimes it works in some completley different way that requires a whole help file to explain (Hello Bubba). I like that. Another example is guild racks, as different guilds have different ways of sorting their items, some better than others. It's the same with libraries. Some index stuff differently than others, some lets you read things without first "borrowing" a book, some let's you select a book based on a numbers, other require the full title to be entered, etc. I can't help it, but I think it's perfectly fine that it works in different ways in different places. Some libraries are just better than others. I mean, the great library of some famous city would likely have a much better system than a pile of scrolls in a barbarian guild...
I totally understand what you mean, though, and I understand why you feel that way, but I just don't agree
But like I said, if the syntaxes are just plain bad and confusing, we should try to fix them, but I don't see the need to standardise every library so it works in exactly the same way everywhere. I think the more we standardise stuff, the more we also lose some of the uniqueness of different places.
Well, it would of course depend on how long the titles are and if it's case-sensitive or not, and just how annoying it actually is for the player. If the titles are 100 characters and it's case sensitive, than yes, I do think it should be fixed. If it's short titles that are quick to type, and case doesn't matter, then maybe it's not such a big issue? But like I said, I think it's better to try to fix the _worst_ ones, that really are annoying, than to try to create a global library system. It's much more realistic that will happen - if you contact the liege / aop directly about the worst libraries.