Smiths has two elements, though. The title is indeed only determined by guild xp (a percentage of combat, questing, and general xp). However, the guild item (necklace) is improved based on forging and crafting.Alteor wrote:Smiths is the most insane guild: when you fail to increase your skill, it tells you that you need to craft more... but crafting more doesn't improve your skill limit at all, only combat XP does... it is totally nuts.
Note: I say this exclusively with mortal knowledge.
